proportions and many folks believe that there were more movies than there were (this is likely due to Doris making a lot of films of a similar vein, but with Cary Grant, Rod Taylor and, especially, James Garner taking on the male role.) First came 1959's Pillow Talk, a fluffy, fun, sophisticated concoction that allowed both stars to show off previously untapped talents and assets. That spectacularly successful movie was followed up in 1961 with Lover Come Back. It is enjoyable as well, but is my least favorite of the three because R & D aren't together enough in it for my tastes. Finally, in 1964, they were again teamed up in Send Me No Flowers.This time out, the stars played, for the first and only time, a married couple. Thus, there was no need for wolfish Rock to try to break down the
The property first saw the light of day as a Broadway play, performing only forty performances in late-1960 to early 1961. David Wayne and Nancy Olson starred in it. Adapted for the screen by Julius Epstein, he was best known for co-writing the script for Casablanca and is also noted for having given a clever answer to the House Un-American Activities Committee. After Jack Warner, who appreciated him and his twin brother Philip's talent, but disliked their approach to working, gave their names to the committee,
Director Norman Jewison, then under contract to Universal Studios, was in the middle of a string of frothy comedies foisted on him in his early career. He would later segue into more serious works as well as musicals and other types of comedies resulting in Oscar nominations for In the Heat of the Night, Fiddler on the Roof and Moonstruck. In 1999, he was given the Irving Thalberg Memorial Award for his body of work.
The chatty, gossipy milkman arrives and fills her in on some of the latest juicy gossip while filling her arms with the various specialty dairy products that Hudson seems to require. As she's coming back inside, she spies the mail in the mail slot of her front door and tugs at it, inadvertently locking herself out with arms full! That's only the beginning of her trouble as she desperately tries to extricate herself from the situation. It's a fun scene that shows off Doris' physical comedy ability nicely.Before his appointment, he lunches with an acquaintance who's known for being a merciless skirt-chaser
and who preys on freshly divorced (or nearly divorced) ladies by pretending to be there for them in their hour of despair. (The restaurant, by the way, symbolically features dismembered statues of women!) The irony here is that the straight-in-real-life actor, Hal March, comes off as extremely effeminate while the gay-in-real-life Hudson comes off as straight as an arrow by contrast!
From the minute Randall hears about Hudson's impending demise, which is discussed with their faces only inches apart, Randall, half lit, can't seem to keep his hands off of Hudson! His character is married (to an unseen wife) but he is completely focused on Hudson and is continually given chances to paw on him, compliment him and, later in the film, share a bed with him, though obviously all within the realm of comedic discomfort.First, he goes off to visit a cemetery where the hilariously
gregarious Paul Lynde is on hand as a plot salesman. Lynde, in his typically smarmy, snarky way, delights in sharing all the benefits of his establishment, but is disenchanted when he finds out that Hudson's family consists of only him and his wife. It's an amusing vignette that Lynde milks for all the humor he can get out of it without ever heading completely over the top. Despite his fourth billing, he only has this scene and one more brief one near the end of the movie.
He and a couple of other gents are ruled out, so the guys take a cart onto the golf course to see if there are any further prospects. Day is playing a few holes and happens to have chosen a cart that's brakes give out, causing her to careen out of control, eventually soaring through a section of the course that's being watered by some heavy duty sprinklers!
Luckily, she is rescued by someone dashing who happened to be riding a horse in a nearby field.
This turns out to be none other than the dreamy Clint Walker, one of the handful of actors who could dwarf Hudson in height and brawn. It seems he is an old boyfriend of Day's and she's thrilled to have come across him again. Hudson and Randall start to feel that he might make the next Mr. Right for Doris, so he is invited to a dinner dance at the country club that night.
just has to make an appearance. See the shot here on the right with Ms. Richards, in a customarily attention-getting red dress, to the left of Clint and Doris on the dance floor. For more on Richards, click on the tag Mystery Extra in the column to the right. She had been one of my greatest mysteries until one of my valuable online friends helped me figure out who she was.
At this same dance, March shows up with his latest conquest, a woman heading to divorce court played by Patricia Barry.
Hudson feels he has to warn her against March's nefarious schemes to get her into the sack. Now... Barry is fifth-billed, but has only this one scene. Almost all of it is played either with her back mostly to the audience or in profile. Furthermore, she plays the better part of her scene in a coat room behind several coats and with one particular hanger dangling right over her face! Either this was the worst planned shot of the film or director Norman Jewison despised this woman!Day, unfortunately, mistakes Hudson's kindness for sexual attraction and thinks that he's been distant due to an affair. This kicks off an argument (mostly taking place in a parking lot with a plethora of gorgeous 1960s cars that enthusiasts will love seeing)
Now Day is utterly devoted to her husband and dotes on him, nestles into him and generally fawns all over him, though not giving up hope. She makes plans to take him to the Mayo Clinic for diagnosis and cure. Trouble is, she finds out by sheer chance that Hudson actually has nothing wrong with him at all besides indigestion! Hudson, who really does think he's sick, is baffled by Day's sudden change of heart as she tosses him (and all of his medicines) out.
This is where Hudson has to head next door to Randall's house to spend the night. Doris has doused his pajamas with the contents of a hot water bottle, so Rock has to change into one of his pal's nightshirts. Innocent as it all is, these still photos of the men almost look as if the two gentlemen are getting prepared for a night of passion! (This is partly because Tony is miffed at Rock and is staring him down. Hey...
there's a thin line between love and hate, right?) They bicker like two old queens about whether or not to leave the window open and pile into bed where they complain about each other's feet and toenails. The next morning, poor Tony is shown in a fetal position taking up about one fourth of the mattress while Rock is sprawled out on his belly with all the covers on.Walker takes this opportunity to slip in and be there for Day.
He has a fun sight gag in an otherwise rather thankless part. He pulls up in a teeny, slender sports car that can barely contain his massive frame. The joke, like many others in the film, is punched across with the aid of Frank De Vol's whimsical and pointedly amusing musical score. Some folks don't like this type of zany music, but I find it charming and appreciate the embellishments it gives to the visual humor.Further misunderstanding occurs until the inevitable
Day, in spite of all the wacky goings on, has such a wonderful way of delivering her lines in a way that gives them such a natural authenticity. For example, when she speaks with cereal or toast in her mouth or when she offhandedly
I all but worship Clint Walker and am happy that he was given a chance to do something different here,
but he's mostly wasted. The story lacks a true villain and there's no way that amiable Clint could bring about anyone's true ire. Even Rock has difficulty getting too worked up over him, though he tries to toss a few barbs at him from time to time, which Walker just laughs off good-naturedly. The clothing they have him in, especially in his first scene is very awkward and ill-fitting. He seems so constricted and hunched in it, which is very much at odds with the proud, tall, expansive way he usually stood in his western films and TV shows. And would it have killed them to toss Walker one brief close-up of that gorgeous mug and his ice blue eyes?!This being a suburban romp rather than a big city, professional story, Jean Louis' creations for Doris are mostly less glamorous than fans had become accustomed to i

7 comments:
We all do have different tastes. "Lover Come Back" was my favorite! Mistaken identity was never so much fun.
Thank you so much for this article. I think you really hit all the main points and the few weaknesses of this movie. It could have easily been ten minutes shorter, but as with most of Ms. Day's movies of this period, it hits the ground running and the viewer is caught up in the plot within the first minute. There is one thing that always drives me nuts about this movie. The train station is obviously in southern California, because there are palm trees nearby. Also, the entire movie appears to be filmed on beautiful, sunny days. But when the men are commuting home on the train, the background footage looks like late autumn or even winter northeastern footage. There are not any leaves on the trees. I always wondered how someone did not notice this during production, and either pick different footage or pick a train station that did not so obviously look like it was located in southern California.
Thank you, you two, for visiting The Underworld and for your comments.
dcolp, I never noticed that, myself, and I tend to focus on background things upon repeat viewings. I'll have to check that out next time!
It is always a pleasure to visit your blog. Your articles are well-researched and informative and fun.
I stumbled on this when I was reading your post about Savage Intruder and having watched Lover Come Back last night it was nice to re-visit Doris and Rock. Paul Lynde had 2 of his best moments in Doris films, this and Glass Bottom Boat. That was NOT acting when he was in drag in the ladies room! LOL I would bet he did his own makeup as well! And it was refreshing to see him comically in the funeral profession without being sadly serious like most portrayals. I don't know if I ever mentioned but I rent my apartment on the 2nd floor of a funeral home. I've been here 18 years and before I went full time managing the gift store I work at, I worked downstairs as well. It started by answering the phones when they had to go out on a call and the next thing I knew I was pushing caskets down the church aisle! But it was truly wonderful work and meant something to people.
I enlarged the picture of Clint Walker squeezing his way out of the Jaguar but what I am struck by is how many movies or TV shows have we seen that house in the background featured?! I know I've seen it somewhere else and maybe more than one! Leave It To Beaver, Donna Reed, My Three Sons?
Rock looks so good here and I like how he's not quite as polished as he was in his earlier pictures with Doris. His softer hair hanging a bit on his forehead makes him a lot more approachable and sexier I think. And at least they got his one shirtless scene front and center! But he really does come off as the hot but neurotic neighbor!
The picture of Rock and Clint, Tony and Doris toasting the camera is nice but odd. Clint looks 10 years older than he is in the movie! Or maybe he's on his 5th "martooni"! LOL! Then I realized Rocks hair is parted on the wrong side of his head than all the pictures from the movie! I can only assume the picture's been flopped from the original shot.
I've always enjoyed this movie and there are so many funny moments but I have to say the thing with the teenage dry cleaner guy never made sense to me. Doris dancing around with that kid doesn't seem to fit her character, even as a fantasy. I think it would have made sense if she cavorted with Hal March in Rock's dream. Also unlikely but more of a possibility. I never cared much for Hal, I think he hosted a quiz show but I can't remember what one.
This was fun to read!
BrianB
Hi, Brian. Responding to you quite belatedly, I'm afraid...! I'm glad you liked this vintage post. I might just be dreaming it, but I feel like that house behind Clint's car was also Dr. Marcus Welby's home/office? As this post was done more than 10 years ago (note the reliance on so many tinted lobby cards and still photos), I either didn't have the ability then or didn't realize I did to flip the picture of the foursome so that the people's correct faces were showing! LOL I try to be more aware of that nowadays. Whenever I watched Hal March in this, I could almost smell the cigarette smoke! Ha ha!
Post a Comment